B-12 Deficiency–Treatment Options

by Vegalicious Elena on July 29, 2011

This post is a continuation of B-12 Deficiency Series:

  1. Part 1: Update: B-12 Deficiency and Cookbook
  2. Part 2: B-12 Deficiency–A Road To Recovery
  3. Part 3: What is Vitamin B-12 and How it Works?
  4. Part 4: Can Vitamin B-12 be a Cure for Infertility and stop Miscarriages?
  5. Part 5: Vitamin B-12 Deficiency Can Cause Hair Loss/B-12 Deficiency-the Great Mimicker
  6. Part 6: Vitamin B-12 Deficiency–Who is at Risk?
  7. Part 7: B-12 Deficiency–Diagnosis
  8. Part 8: Purely Happy {B-12 Deficiency Diagnosis}–my tests

With each post we are moving closer to concluding the series on B-12 deficiency. I think besides my How to Reverse Hypothyroidism Naturally post, this is one of the most explosive, in depth, passion driven posts I have ever done, although I am just as passionate about every other subject I blogged about.

Today, having already told you about who might be at risk of B-12 deficiency, how to get it diagnosed and asking for right tests, I am going to tell you about treatment options you can ask for from your doctor, what you can do at home, and what pitfalls to avoid.

The information for this post comes from my research of various studies done on the topic, and also reading Could it Be B12? as well as B-12 Exposed.

Treatment

Safety

First let me start with this, and you might have learned this from my last post, on my personal approach to treatment, once you take your labs [i.e. give your blood and urine], talk to your doctor about starting treatment immediately. B-12 vitamin injections/tablets* are totally safe–you cannot overdose on them, there are no side effects, and it is NOT toxic; so even if you have healthy levels of B-12 you are safe to do injections or take supplements.

*you do not need a prescription to get B-12 in a form of a supplement, so, should you decide not to get tested, although I would strongly suggest it, you can order it on-line [options below], or through your local health food store. 

Just How Safe is B-12?

I recently wrote to Dr. Chandy–the physician in the UK that treats a lot of his patients with B-12 injections; you watched him in the video in this post. I was fortunate to have heard back from his assistant [one who holds a PhD nonetheless ;) ]. Here is what he told me about safety of B-12:

“…one doctor we know of gives 100 mg (100,000 mcg) twice per week by infusion.

What level of B12 could be too much? To put it bluntly, no level is too much. The treatment for cyanide poisoning using B12 is 5 g (5,000 mg or 5 million mcg) and a fireman who inhales smoke without breathing apparatus could get two doses 20 mins apart. I’m told the Paris fire brigade use the B12 treatment routinely, so they might dose their firemen and women more than once per month with these incredibly high doses. It makes their urine turn red (cobalt red not blood red), but I believe they don’t even get to sit out the rest of the shift (nor do they need to). “

Now, if that is not safe, I am not sure what is! So, don’t worry–you simply can’t overdose!

Options

There are several approaches to treating B-12 deficiency. Everyone who is in the danger zone:

  1. 200-300 pg/ml–intermediate deficiency
  2. <200 pg/ml–severe deficiency; and even
  3. 300-450 pg/ml–subtle deficiency

should ask for B-12 injections. You might wonder if there is a reason for it, and the answer is YES! If you take B-12 orally, most of the vitamin gets lost during digestion process. If you have an autoimmune disease or digestive problems, your stomach won’t be able to process of absorb B-12 effectively, so you will be wasting your time and money.

There is a form of B-12 called lozenges, that you can take by placing tablets under your tongue, like a candy, and some of it will absorb through your salivary glands–it is a better option than tablets you have to swallow.

Another option is B-12 nasal spray–which will bypass your digestive system altogether.

There are also B-12 patches you can apply behind your ear, so that B-12 would absorb through your skin, going directly into the blood stream.

With all these options, injections have been proven to be the best way to go–injections are administered into the muscle, which is supposed to store part of our B-12 storage by design already. While all other types of supplementation/treatment might take time to show benefits, with injections a difference can be felt within the same day, especially in those suffering from severe deficiency or neurological deficiency symptoms. However, even if you fall in the gray zone [300-450 pg/ml--subtle deficiency] but are very symptomatic, be emphatic with your doctor to request injections. I would not hesitate to ask for injections even if I came up with 550 pg/ml and was symptomatic–after all, it is my money that pays for it, and again, remember that there is no danger of overdosing!  In addition to that studies* have shown that even omnivores with “normal” B-12 levels can greatly benefit from injections, alleviating such symptoms as depression, and a sense of wellbeing was reported in many. [*Source]

Types of B-12 {Cobalamin} Treatments

B-12 is produced in three forms used for B-12 deficiency treatments:

  1. cyanocobalamin
  2. hydroxocobalamin
  3. methylcobalamin

Studies have shown that hydroxocobalamin is superior to cyanocobalamin, and methylcobalamin is superior to methylcobalamin.

80% of the injected cyanocobalamin dose is excreted within the first 24-hours [Source]. You will be surprised to find out that cyanocobalamin is made with poison–cyanide, and who needs that in their bodies? Not only that but patients with Leber’s neuropathy cannot properly clear cyanide from their system, so cyanocobalamin can be life-threatening to them.

Cyanocobalamin is the WORST choice of B-12!  ”Not only does cyanocobalamin require a higher dosage for the same effectiveness of hydroxocabalamin, but it is entire ineffective for several conditions related to vitamin B-12 deficiency.” [Source]

Since 1970′s several researches presented strong cases to remove cyanocobalamin as an option for treatment altogether. It is unfortunate that the US still has not heeded their educated advice, while Great Britain got on board with their recommendations.

In contrast hydroxocobalamin has a greater retention rate [28-days after injection retention rates is nearly three times greater than cyanocobalamin], and it is more available to cells and is processed more efficiently by them. [Source]

Methylcobalamin, as you have read in my last post, unfortunately is not as familiar in the US, not even to doctors. Methylcobalamin, unlike its two less effective cousins, “bypasses several potentially problematic steps of B-12 metabolism. Furthermore, methylcobalamin provides the body with methyl groups essential for various biological oxidation-reductions. Studies show that a small oral dose of methylcobalamin results in a greater accumulation of cobalamin in the liver than an oral dose of cyanocobalamin, and methylcobalamin is retained approximately three times longer in the tissue than cyanocobalamin.” [Source]

“Degenerative neurological problems are where methylcobalamin shows its greatest benefits over other cobalamin preparations, and it is often one of the ONLY promising treatments for these tragic diseases. While Japan uses methylcobalamin nearly exclusively and it is the form present in prescription vitamin B-12 there, the United States has virtually ignored the hundreds of studies that show the benefits this simple vitamin can bring.” [Source]

With this information you should be outraged to see cyanocobalamin in pre-natal vitamins, which unfortunately is the case.

How Much B-12?

If you are low and your doctor agrees to B-12 injections, assuming that you will request methylcobalamin [fight for it tooth and nail--it will be worth your money], the author of Could it Be B12? book, Sally M Pacholok, RN, suggest the following regimen:

  1. Initial intramuscular injections of B12—1,000 mcg daily or every other day for 5-7 days, followed by
  2. Intramuscular injections of B12—1,000 mcg weekly for four weeks, followed by
  3. Intramuscular injections of B12—1,000 mcg either weekly, bi-weekly or monthly, to be individualized for each patient.

Patients can get their injections at their doctor’s office, or, if you are a brave soul like me and wish to save money, you can ask your physician, or his/her nurse, to teach you how to give injections yourself.

When ordering methylcobalamin from a pharmacy, ask for the one without preservatives, if at all possible.

The bi-monthly/monthly injections after the initial treatment can be maintained as long as needed, for some for the rest of their lives, or, if you are able to properly and easily absorb B-12 vitamin through other forms of supplementation, the upkeep can be done with those options.

Personally, we are going to go through 3 months of injection treatment, then we will have a check up and either continue with injections or/and switch to sublingual form of B-12. We are also planning to supplement with sublingual B-12 in-between our shots, once we go on a biweekly regimen. Again, remember that B-12 is not toxic and you cannot overdose, so doing both, injections and supplementation is totally safe.

Sublingual and Oral Dosage

If you, or your doctor, for one reason or another, decide that you are not doing injections, when choosing B-12 supplementation, look for the same options as in injections–methycobalamin is still the best way to go.

There are many dosage options out on the market. When I shopped for B-12 for the first time a couple of years back, I found options ranging from 25 mcg/dose to 6,000+ mcg/dose. At the time I did not know any better and settled for 500 mcg lozenges. Had I known then what I know now I would have gone with at least 2,000-5,000+ mcg/dose. If you read my first article, you know that even a short treatment with 5,000 mcg/day of B-12 provided a huge relief to my muscle spasms–something I had not experienced for years.

I can tell you, however, that 6 mcg, 25 mcg, or even 100 mcg, are not going to make much of a difference even for people with normal levels of B-12.  It is like a grain of sand on a large beach–it will be lost and you would have wasted your precious time and money.  I know that it can be misleading to read on a bottle that the dosage you take is 8000% of daily value–remember that a lot of it gets lost in the absorption/retention process.

And yet again, remember that YOU CANNOT OVERDOSE WITH B-12! So, don’t be timid and afraid to go for 5,000 mcg of B-12 or more a day.

What I Use

The moment my blood was drawn today, since I was holding off on supplementing with B-12 for the last week and a half, I popped in a 5,000 mcg lozenge into my mouth, and later in the day followed up with another one.  Can you blame me?  I just want to feel better FAST!

I used Jarrow formula of methylcobalamin, which also happens to be safe for vegans to use:

The same company produces a different strength of this supplement:

There are other formulas that come recommended by those in the vegan community:

choose between 1000 and 5000 mcg

Liquid option of methylcobalamin:
and a couple of patches of methylcobalamin:
and

In the next two posts I will tell you about the dangers of B-12 deficiency, if left untreated, and give you a list of sources used in my research for this series.

________________________________________

I initially missed to add the next section in the Diagnosis post, which I have now updated, but I am including it here for the benefit of those who already read that article.

Where to get Urinary MMA

Urinary MMA, aka uMMA, stands for urinary methylmalonic acid.  The test measures methylmalonic acid (MMA) by selected ion monitoring isotope dilution gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC/MS) in a random spot urine specimen. The MMA value is normalized to urine creatinine to correct for urine dilution. The urinary MMA/creatinine ratio (uMMA) test is more accurate than the blood test as it indicates tissue/cellular B12 deficiency.

If it happens that you do not have an insurance, or your insurance does not cover uMMA, which they should, you can go directly to the source to have it done for $150 per test–it’s a small price to pay compared to what you might have to pay if you don’t catch the deficiency in time to get it treated!

Norman Clinical Laboratory, Inc. (NCL) provides a means to test individuals through the mail for cobalamin (vitamin B12 ) deficiency. NCL, established in 1985, was the first commercial laboratory to provide the uMMA test. NCL introduced the Mayo Clinic to the uMMA assay and Mayo Clinic has also provided the uMMA test for years. Now other laboratories around the world are offering the uMMA test which has benefited thousands.

The lab is located in Cincinnati OH [go, Ohio!], and the turnaround time for the test results is around 3 days, once they have your sample.  All you have to do is call them [800-397-7408] and ask for them to mail you materials and container needed for the test, and they will respond immediately. I called them, just in case if our insurance did not cover the test.  Having left a message I heard back from them within an hour, and in a couple of days I received all I needed to collect a sample in the mail, along with instructions on how to do it.

Complete B12 Research

To get the entire report of my B12 research either:

  1. subscribe and download the 180-page report, which had an entire Appendix dedicate to the topic (the entire research, and how the findings helped me), or
  2. go through B-12 category on this site, starting from the earliest post.

Related posts:

  1. Chemical Free Laundry Options {Living Healthy}
  2. Vitamin B-12 Deficiency Can Cause Hair Loss
  • http://simplydarlene.wordpress.com/ Simply Darlene

    Hey Elena,

    Just curious, have you found pros and cons regarding taking 3000mcg every 3 days vs. taking 1000mcg each day? Maybe you already covered this someplace and I missed it… I am skipping around in these b-12 posts a lot.  (Please email me your response too. I asked it here in case anyone else was wondering the same thing.)

    Blessings.

    • http://www.vega-licious.com/ Elena

      Darlene, 1000 mcg of injectible B12 would assimilate and absorb better than 3000 mcg–since it is water soluble.  So, the strategy is to do 1000 mcg for 7 days, then 1000 mcg once a week, and then 1000 mcg bi-weekly, and in between you can take sublingual b12 methy. You cannot overdose, however, so even if you did inject 3000 mcg you won’t hurt yourself.  The goal is not to waste any though :)

  • Pingback: Vitamin B-12 Treatment Update

  • Paul28feb

    What about taking 1000MCG 3 times throughout the day? Would this help?

    • http://www.vega-licious.com/ Elena

      I am sure that it would–just make sure it is methylcobalamin, not the other forms of it. I am sure you will feel a difference.  You are safe to go as high as you want. Currently, between shots, I am using 5000 mcg every other day. 

  • Pingback: A Happy Interlude {Vitamin B-12 Infertility Treatment}

  • Pingback: B-12 Deficiency Update {Benefits of Treatment}

  • Pingback: What are the Best Prenatal Vitamins? {Vegan Pregnancy}

  • Rachelle Marsden

    Hi Elena, what about for young vegan children? What would you do for their B12? Sorry if I just missed this somewhere. I have two little ones who have been 75%-100% vegan all of their lives but they are so young, I wouldn’t give them the shots and they can’t swallow pills. My 12 month old is breastfed, so perhaps he would get enough just through my intake? Thanks for your help!

    • http://www.vega-licious.com/ Elena

      I would not do shots for them either ;) I am planning to start mine off at about 8-12 mos of age with liquid B12 (I read about age recommendation of 6-12 mos as starting age in one of the VEGAN HOW TO books written by either ND or a dietician/nutritionist… can’t remember now ;) ).  I have not tried this one yet, but something I am planning to do: 
      http://astore.amazon.com/vega-licious-20/detail/B0038NZ3KS  You cannot overdose with B12, so this dosage or slightly less will do.  I am planning to try massaging it into baby’s mouth, or foods.  I might start with smaller dosage (about 1000 mcg or so… again, no fear of overdose, but some is better than none ;) ). 

      • Rachelle Marsden

         Elena, Somehow at the store I got confused and thought Cyanocobalamin was the best rather than the worst form and bought them. :( Would you suggest just using what  I have or trying to return them? I feel rather foolish!

        • Rachelle Marsden

           We’re going to return it. :)

          • http://www.vega-licious.com/ Elena

            yes, if you can, do :)

Previous post:

Next post: